Ethical Principles and Participant Protection
EJMCR, published by Discover STM Publishing Ltd, protects the rights, dignity, safety, privacy and confidentiality of patients and research participants. Manuscripts involving people, patient information or clinical material must meet the ethical and legal requirements that apply to the work and follow the principles of the World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki (2024). The editors check ethics approval and patient confidentiality as part of the editorial assessment.
Research Ethics Approval
Research involving people must be reviewed and approved by an independent ethics committee. Authors must name the approving committee (Institutional Review Board or Research Ethics Committee) and institution, and give the approval number and date. If the study was exempt, or approval was not needed, authors must explain why and provide evidence if the editors ask for it. The editors may question the ethics of a study even when a committee has approved it, taking account of local rules and international principles.
Approval Before the Study Starts
Ethics approval must be obtained before the research begins. Approval obtained afterwards does not correct research that needed approval and started without it. If approval was needed but not obtained, authors must explain why; the editors assess the explanation and may ask the authors’ institution to review it. Retrospective studies are not exempt by default: using existing records, identifiable data or stored samples may need ethics review, a formal exemption or an approved waiver of consent.
Case Reports, Case Series and Reviews
A single case report about routine clinical care may not need research ethics approval, depending on local rules, but patient confidentiality and consent for publication always apply. For a case series, the need for ethics approval depends on how it was designed and how the data were collected, not on the number of patients. Authors must state whether approval was obtained or why it was not needed. A review of published literature does not normally need ethics approval, unless it uses unpublished data that could identify people. Case reports should follow the CARE reporting guideline.
Consent to Take Part in Research
Participants must give voluntary, informed consent to take part in research, after receiving clear information about the study. Consent to treatment is not consent to take part in research. Where the law and an ethics committee allow it, a waiver of individual consent may apply, for example in some retrospective studies.
Consent for Publication
Consent for publication is separate from consent for treatment or for taking part in research. For any patient who could be identified, authors must obtain written informed consent for publication. The patient, or their authorised representative, should be able to see the material to be published and understand that it will be available online. Authors must state in the manuscript that consent for publication was obtained. Details that are not needed must be removed; removing the name or hospital number alone may not be enough to prevent identification. If there is any doubt that a patient can remain anonymous, consent for publication must be obtained. A signed research consent form does not cover publication of identifiable details.
Children, Patients Unable to Consent and Deceased Patients
When a patient cannot give consent, authors must obtain it from a parent, guardian or legally authorised representative, as local law requires. The wishes of a child or other patient should be respected as far as possible. For deceased patients, the duty of confidentiality continues and local legal requirements apply; being a relative does not by itself give the right to consent. If valid consent cannot be obtained, the editors will consider the case and may seek ethical or legal advice. Publishing without consent is not a normal alternative, even if the patient has died, cannot consent or cannot be contacted.
Privacy, Confidentiality and Clinical Images
Authors must protect patient confidentiality in the text, tables, photographs, scans and videos. Names, initials, record numbers, faces, distinctive features, exact dates or places, and combinations of clinical details can identify a patient. Covering only the eyes in a facial photograph is not enough. Images must show findings accurately; any change to an image must be stated and must not alter its clinical meaning. The editors may ask for evidence of consent or for the original, de-identified images, as described in the Guide for Authors. Consent forms and identifiable records must be sent to the Editorial Office in confidence and are not published or routinely sent to reviewers.
Animal Research
Research on animals must follow institutional, national and international animal-welfare standards. Authors must report the ethics approval or oversight for the work and describe how the animals were cared for.
Ethical Concerns
If the editors or reviewers have concerns about ethics approval, consent, confidentiality or research conduct, the editors will ask the authors for an explanation and supporting documents. Depending on the outcome, the editors may ask for revisions, reject the manuscript, or take action after publication, as set out in the Corrections, Retractions and Expressions of Concern policy. Serious concerns are referred to the authors’ institution. Clinical trials must be registered as described in the Editorial and Publishing Policies.
Last reviewed: November 2026
Policy responsibility: EJMCR Editorial Office, in accordance with Discover STM Publishing Ltd policies.
Related guidance:
WMA Declaration of Helsinki (2024)
ICMJE Protection of Research Participants
CARE case-report guidance
COPE principles of transparency and best practice
Discover STM Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement
EJMCR Guide for Authors
EJMCR Editorial and Publishing Policies
EJMCR Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern
EJMCR Publishing Ethics and Publication Malpractice Statement