EJMCR, published by Discover STM Publishing Ltd, assesses every submission editorially and uses double-anonymised (double-blind) peer review. This page sets out how peer review works at EJMCR.
Initial Editorial Assessment
Every submission is first assessed by the editors. They consider whether it fits the journal’s aims and scope, the article type, whether the submission requirements are met, originality, reporting quality, ethics, and clinical or scientific validity. Manuscripts that are outside the scope, do not meet the requirements, or have serious methodological or ethical problems are declined before external review.
Peer Review
Manuscripts that proceed beyond initial assessment are reviewed as follows:
| Article type | Type of review |
|---|---|
| Original Articles, Review Articles, Case Reports, Case Series, Clinical Audits | At least two independent external reviewers with relevant expertise (double-anonymised) |
| Short Communications, Technical Notes, Surgical Videos, Illustrative Techniques, Letters to the Editor, Image Articles | Reviewed; depending on the content, by one or more external reviewers, an internal reviewer, or editorial assessment only |
| Editorials (by invitation only) | Editorial review |
In every case, the editor considers the reviews and makes the final decision.
EJMCR does not use peer reviews transferred from other journals. Reviewers must declare any conflicts of interest and keep manuscripts confidential. External peer review is double-anonymised: authors and reviewers do not know each other’s identity.
You can read our Editorial & Peer Review Process here.
Reviewer Responsibilities
Reviewers give objective, constructive assessments suited to the type of manuscript. They assess the clinical or scientific value, methods, interpretation and reporting; point out strengths and weaknesses; explain their recommendations; and tell the editor about any ethical or integrity concerns. Reviewers must keep the manuscript confidential, declare any competing interests, and decline if they cannot be impartial.
Confidentiality
Manuscripts, reviewer reports and editorial correspondence are confidential. Reviewers must not share any part of a manuscript. A reviewer who wants advice from a colleague must ask the editor first. Unpublished information must not be used for personal or professional gain. Confidential information is disclosed only where the law requires it.
Use of Artificial Intelligence by Reviewers and Editors
Reviewers and editors must not upload manuscripts, patient information, text, images or data to public AI tools that cannot keep them confidential. They remain responsible for their own reports and decisions, and AI must not replace their judgement. Any language help must protect confidentiality, and the reviewer or editor remains responsible for the final text. See also EJMCR’s Instructions for Reviewers.
Competing Interests
Reviewers must declare any financial, professional or personal interests and decline an invitation where an interest could affect, or appear to affect, their impartiality. Editors must also declare their interests and step aside from manuscripts where they have a conflict.
Manuscripts by Editors and Board Members
Manuscripts submitted by an editor or editorial board member are handled by another editor. The author takes no part in the review or the decision, and the usual double-blind peer review applies.
Editorial Decisions and Further Review
Reviewers advise; the handling editor makes the final decision, based on the manuscript’s merit, integrity and fit with EJMCR. If the reviews disagree, the editor may ask for clarification or another expert opinion. The editor also decides whether a revised manuscript needs further review.
Editorial Independence and Research Integrity
Editorial decisions are independent of article processing charges and any other commercial interest. Payment does not affect the decision or guarantee acceptance. Concerns about plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, image or data manipulation, unethical research, authorship or other misconduct are handled under the journal’s ethics policies. The editors first ask the authors for an explanation; where an investigation is needed, the matter is referred to the authors’ institution.
Last reviewed: November 2026.